Webdiary - Independent, Ethical, Accountable and Transparent
header_02 home about login header_06
sidebar-top content-top

Frank Hardy: Politics, Literature, Life, by Jenny Hocking

Chris Saliba was working on this piece when Margo decided to retire from Webdiary, and had originally intended to submit it to her. He has been an occasional contributor to Webdiary from the SMH days. His last piece was On democracy and war with Scott Ritter.

Chris submitted this review with a personal thankyou to Margo. Very pleased to have you with us Chris and thankyou!

Frank Hardy: Politics, Literature, Life, by Jenny Hocking
Reviewed by Chris Saliba

Jenny Hocking is Deputy Director of the National Centre for Australian Studies at Monash University and has written books on politics, politicians and Australian counter-terrorism laws [Jenny's last piece for Webdiary was When scrutiny, secrecy and security collide]. Frank Hardy: Politics, Literature, Life is not so much a conventional biography of a writer as a kaleidoscope of history, politics, biography and literature. More pointedly, Jenny Hocking explores the role of fact in the making of fiction, and leaves the reader pondering: What is the role of the politically committed fiction writer in times of upheaval and discord?

Hocking cites pacifist and anti-fascist Egon Erwin Kisch as an early influence on Frank Hardy, with his view that fiction had been rendered obsolete by the horrors of the First World War, to be supplanted by fact based writing as a new form of fiction.

The case of Kisch is an interesting one, with numerous parallels to today. The Czech author had been an inmate of the Nazi’s concentration camps. He accepted an invitation from the Movement Against War and Fascism to speak at its anti-war congress in Melbourne. Yet Robert Menzies, then Attorney-General in the Lyons government, felt he was more a Communist proselytizer and famously determined that ‘he shall not set foot on the soil of the Australian Commonwealth.’ (Recall how John Howard made similar boasts about asylum seekers on the Tampa.)

Kisch jumped ship, was dragged back on the Strathaird and eventually disembarked at Sydney. What followed was a game of cat and mouse through the courts, until Menzies’ plan came undone, the High Court judging that the exclusion of Kisch from Australia had been invalid. (Scott Parkin comes to mind in 2005.)

The book also reminds how Menzies was an admirer of Hitler. After Menzies’ 1938 visit to Germany, the Attorney-General was moved to say, ‘Hitler is not an administrator as Mussolini is. He is a dreamer, a man of ideas, many of them good ones.’ In that same year Menzies even went so far as to say that he ‘thought it was a great thing for Germany to have arms.’

Another historical curiosity is the appearance of the German aristocrat, Count Felix von Luckner, on Australian shores. On June 6, 1938, at the Sydney Town Hall, the Count held a gig in which he demonstrated Aryan supremacy by ripping up telephone books and bending pennies, all the while telling the audience how happy Germany was. Sydney’s rich and powerful filled the front row seats. On the Count’s arrival in Sydney, he was welcomed by a private audience with Prime Minister Joe Lyons. 

Eight years later, Frank Hardy would start work on his most famous novel, Power Without Glory. It was written with the express purpose of lifting the veil on the corruption within politics, most notably within the Labor Party. (One thinks of Mark Latham’s Diaries today doing the same job.) Throughout his life Hardy harboured a mistrust of parliamentary politics, and later admitted he had worked throughout his life for a communist dictatorship in Australia.

Power Without Glory is an odd novel, in that it was actually commissioned by the Communist Party. Hardy was provided financial backing by the Party for four years; he also had a swag of party members act as researchers. The novel in a lot of ways reads like blockbuster fiction, yet doesn’t really have a plot, rather it piles political intrigue upon political intrigue, until you feel quite sick at the canker in the democratic bud. This was pretty much Hardy’s goal: a book aimed at moral improvement, not so much of the reader, but of the current political culture.

Writes Hocking:

"The Communist Party’s strategy intersected with Hardy’s interest in attempting an epic political novel as expose. It was suggested that a book written around the successful and dynamic financier and Victorian Labor Party identity John Wren, sufficiently disguised to avoid prosecution, yet obvious enough to ensure popular declamation, would be a unique form of political strategy as literature."

Hocking’s interest in ASIO also provides much interesting detail from the period of the Australian Communist Party’s heyday. Again, reading through this history one is struck by the parallels to today, especially the fact that the Labor Party passed the Communist Party Dissolution Act 1950, for fear of appearing soft on communism. Indeed, the past is prologue!

Prior to the passing of the Dissolution Act on October 23, 1950, the Menzies Government had received an ASIO report on what the Communist Party was up to. While admitting that support for the Communist Party was waning, nevertheless ASIO provided lists of groups that were sympathetic, yet not members of the party. The groups fingered for attention were the likes of The New Housewives Association, the Fellowship of Australian Writers and the Sydney Technical College’s Student’s Union. ASIO also provided lists of people to be interred in case of war.

As you can see, life was a sea of troubles if you were a member of the Communist Party of Australia during the ban. ASIO’s file on Hardy was so prodigious that it had a habit of casting black clouds on innocent bystanders: Hardy’s son, Alan, had his details indexed. He was seven years old at the time.

The second half of Frank Hardy: Politics Literature Life concentrates more on Hardy’s somewhat haphazard literary output over the following years (after Power Without Glory’s 1950 publication, he didn’t write his next novel until 1958) and his personal life. There were the love affairs with Greek songbird Nana Mouskouri and Rumanian actress Elena Arama. The destructive addiction to gambling. Not one to pay his bills, despite his Marxist education and sure knowledge that he must be living off the labour of others, he could be found lining up with kids at busted phone booths in order to make a free call. Hardy even received a letter from some angry battlers after not paying one of his removalist bills: “We are a company of battlers and cannot survive when people, like yourselves, do not pay their debts!’

How different we are from what we profess ourselves to be.

The book also contains a nice little section on Mary Hardy, Frank’s youngest sister by fourteen years. I always had to be in bed by the time her show The Penthouse Club started, but I instinctively knew at that young age that Mary Hardy’s wit and snappy one liners were something to be celebrated – Australia’s answer to Dorothy Parker. Her life was pretty miserable too, ending in suicide in 1985.

She went out with a bang though. In 1983 Mary stormed a Liberal Party Function in Sydney. It was a $500 a pop fundraiser. Newly elected PM Malcolm Fraser and wife Tammy were the guests of honour. After interjecting during Fraser’s speech and making crow calls during Colleen Hewitt’s rendition of the Liberal Party theme song (is that available on CD I wonder?) she was taken to Redfern police station.

Jenny Hocking’s Frank Hardy, Politics, Literature, Life, with its theme of politics as literature, will keep your mind wonderfully focused on the role of the writer, and his or her responsibilities during times of upheaval and change, which is just about every day these days.

Published by Lothian Books.

[ category: ]

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.


Frank Hardy became the darling of the literary establishment, but I think his later books were only just poor quality communist propaganda.

Had the Communists come to power in Australia, Hardy would have been liquidated as too romantic.

When I was a child

When I was a child, my mother bought this book and glued into it the sections of the daily papers that identified the protagonists.  Her excitement was palpabIe. I had the feeling, only crystallised when I was older, that the establishment was so powerful and pervasive at the time that any undermining of main players  was not only brave but almost seditious.

re: Frank Hardy: Politics, Literature, Life, by Jenny Hocking

I will have to get this book.

Power Without Glory was republished as a thick paperback in the sixties. I can still see the image on the cover. A cake in the form of a map of Australia with a slice missing. I bought it in a newsagency in Queensland without having much idea of what I was buying, and no idea of who Frank Hardy was.

Fortunately my parents knew exactly. My mother had bought a hardcopy of the first edition at the CPA office in Flinders Lane, under the counter, in 1950.

They were able to tell me in considerable detail who were the characters and places.

As it turned out the book was an immense early influence. It was one of a few that triggered my interest in politics. I ended up reading most of Frank Hardy's stuff over the next few years but have never got around to his latter work.

Thank you for the review.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
© 2005-2011, Webdiary Pty Ltd
Disclaimer: This site is home to many debates, and the views expressed on this site are not necessarily those of the site editors.
Contributors submit comments on their own responsibility: if you believe that a comment is incorrect or offensive in any way,
please submit a comment to that effect and we will make corrections or deletions as necessary.
Margo Kingston Photo © Elaine Campaner

Recent Comments

David Roffey: {whimper} in Not with a bang ... 12 weeks 5 days ago
Jenny Hume: So long mate in Not with a bang ... 12 weeks 6 days ago
Fiona Reynolds: Reds (under beds?) in Not with a bang ... 13 weeks 1 day ago
Justin Obodie: Why not, with a bang? in Not with a bang ... 13 weeks 1 day ago
Fiona Reynolds: Dear Albatross in Not with a bang ... 13 weeks 1 day ago
Michael Talbot-Wilson: Good luck in Not with a bang ... 13 weeks 1 day ago
Fiona Reynolds: Goodnight and good luck in Not with a bang ... 13 weeks 2 days ago
Margo Kingston: bye, babe in Not with a bang ... 13 weeks 6 days ago