Webdiary - Independent, Ethical, Accountable and Transparent
header_02 home about login header_06
header_07
search_bar_left
date_box_left
date_box_right.jpg
search_bar_right
sidebar-top content-top

Are you an Antisemite?

Identifying as an antisemite is about as fashionable as toothbrush moustaches and invading Poland. This may be appropriate because this month is the anniversary of the publication in 1925 of Mein Kampf, an occasion that American commentator Walter Russell Mead has marked with this excellent piece The Hate That Dares Not Speak Its Name.

We know how precious the Israel bashing left can get about any suggestion of antisemitism on its part. So offended and indignant they are always compelled to deny it. True. Well, pretty much always. "Just because I criticise Israel does not mean I'm an antisemite!" "Just because I am concerned for the rights of the Palestinians doesn't mean I'm an antisemite!" And on and on and on ... If you are lucky you may even get a scoffing and sniffy dismissal of the very suggestion. Fairfax does that well. Very occasionally the denial is offensive and faintly threatening. "If you suggest that by standing up for the rights of the Palestinians I am an antisemite, then so be it, I am an antisemite.!" Ahuh. The problem with all of this is that the suggestion is always theirs.

This is called the pre-emptive defensive denial and it has been talked about here before. It is part of the armoury of any typical anti-Zionist or no particular Israel basher in general. The phenomenon is so widespread it is a defining feature of the assault on Israel from Europe and the left and has been for decades. Go to anywhere indulging in a spot of nasty Israel bashing and you will see it.

You don't have to go as far as Europe or even necessarily to the left, of course Here's an example from just across the Tasman. By this I mean the disgusting spectacle last week about the Israeli backpackers.

For those who missed it here's the story in a nutshell. Or should I say nutshall.

A young Israeli tourist is killed in Christchurch a little while ago along with a lot of other people and his friends stranded and their government does its job so well it gets accused of spying.

On New Zealand.

That's pretty much it really.

Check out the blogs and what passes for comment in silly little provincial NZ. Suddenly NZ is awash with non-antisemites. We know this because they say so A lot. Much of the content that points out Israel is evil and that mossad is everywhere is devoted to denying antisemitism. About 30% I'd say. Meanwhile a young Israeli tourist tragically killed in the Christchurch earthquake, and his traumatised friends, and their families have been treated by the NZ media in a way that would disgust us all had it been our kids, or young kiwis, involved. The performance of the Israeli government, by the way, in reaching and bringing home their people, and being able to deliver real practical aid on the ground to local emergency services on the other side of the world, would delight us had the kids been Aussies caught up in such a horrible thing. Surely?

Not so for some New Zealanders it seems. For them this could only mean Mossad. Theyyy'ree backkk ...they'll get that godamn kiwi passport no matter what.. even if it means deploying the earthquake gun!

I don't want to pick on the poor Kiwis. They have enough troubles after making global gooses of themselves and anyway I digress.

The question is are you an antisemite?

The reason I ask is because I would prefer it if people stopped asking me. I have no idea. Just as well. That would require an exploration of the darker inner reaches of your mind and that thankfully is not my line. Ultimately it's a question for you really. Just as ultimately it's up to you to do something about it.

I do know there's a lot of it about. I also know that it inflames much of the debate on Israel/Palestine just as surely as it inflames the dispute itself.

So to help you with your question

Walter Russell Mead says:

The truth is that anti-Semitism is alive and well and not even particularly rare; it’s just that many of today’s anti-Semites like to think of themselves as enlightened, modern people and get all huffy and hissy if anyone accuses them of prejudice in any form. Many who in past times would have been open and honest about their anti-Semitism, now try to hide the truth even from themselves.

I agree.

Meade has identified what he calls the "five pillars of anti-Semitism" which perhaps can be a test. These are belief in any of the following ideas:

  • Jews are more clannish than other people and act in concert to support a specifically Jewish agenda.
  • Jews deploy extraordinary wealth with almost superhuman cunning in support of the Jewish agenda.
  • As a religious and national minority, Jews cannot flourish without attacking the traditional values of their host society. In every country Jews seek to weaken national culture, religion, values and cohesion.
  • Jews are not a national group or a people in the way that others are; they do not have the same right to establish a nation state that other peoples do.
  • Where Jewish interests are concerned, the appearance of open debate in our society and many others is a carefully constructed illusion. In reality, Jews work together to block open debate on issues they care about and those who resist the Jewish agenda are marginalized in public discussion.

Remember, the question is are you an antisemite not whether you are a nazi. Mead says:

You don’t have to believe them all — any one will do. Being an anti-Semite does not necessarily make you a Nazi. You are an anti-Semite. That doesn’t make you a Nazi; Hitler added a sixth pillar of anti-Semitism that the only way to successfully oppose the Jewish agenda was to kill all the Jews.

Since Hitler’s death, the world has defined anti-Semitism down. Nurturing ancient fantasies of secret Jewish cabals that control the media and play politicians like puppets on a string, and making political judgments based on these fantasies isn’t sort of or almost anti-Semitic. To believe that Jews control public discourse and the media and bend the gentile masses to their sinister agenda is the essence of old fashioned anti-Semite. In some countries these beliefs are so common that they are no longer recognized as an aggressive and communicable mental disease. These ideas have become so widely accepted that they are seldom questioned or examined; when that happens, a whole society is poisoned and distorted.

So? How did you go? I reckon Meade has got a pretty good benchmark going here. Do you have any of ideas? Any one of them?

Mead says:

On the anniversary of Mein Kampf‘s publication people of good will everywhere should remember the need to fight one of the most vicious forms of prejudice that the world has ever known. Prejudice never recognizes itself; anti-Semites honestly think their delusional beliefs about Jews are simple, obvious truths. They are not; all five of those beliefs are demonstrably false.

In Nazi Germany people were imprisoned and even killed for trying to fight anti-Semitism. In America we are free to fight it, but too many of us choose to ignore this hate that dares not speak its name. Anti-Semitism is real, it is murderous, and it is very much with us today. Speak the truth and shame the devil. Whatever your religion, your politics, your views about Israeli policy, fighting anti-Semitism is part of what it means to be a decent human being.

We must all do our part to keep this filthy hatred in the ignominious pit where it belongs.

left
right
[ category: ]
spacer

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Mike - too late mate

Z i O N M A N i A

***namaste***

Mike,

A fantastic idea, I wish iWinnie had thought about it, but it's a moot point. 

You see, at present I'm staring an empty flagon of brown muscat in the faces. Such a decision is out of my paws. Geoff must have accepted the offer (although it would appear he exercised the option on the olive).

Now doubt Geoff and your good-self share a mind, a beautiful mind, a colourful mind, and share incredibly good ideas as well.

You see, Geoff has already been hard at it, renovating, painting and building higher tops on the mountains, in order to accommodate all those Tibetans who want to share your safe haven.

It's been an expensive task but as you can see the infrastructure has been underwritten (and promoted) by Swiss banker iHarry iHeidelberg.

Already things are happening: Jewish doctors have been doing a roaring trade removing superfluous digits from the extremities of the home team, kids are learning to cypher, instead of syphon, and boat loads of Tibetians are being greeted as we speak.

Thank-you both for showing the rest of the world how beautiful minds can do incredible things.

Letter from Hobart

My pleasure Justin.

The Tibetans are settling in beautifully as you would expect. They are a beautiful people. Nice of you to ask.The only bit of nastiness was when the Jewish buddhists used their numbers to force through a plan that sets up the Dalai Lama  in his own palace and temple right on the very top of Mt Wellington. Some of the orthodox rabbis got pretty toey about that, I can tell you. Anyway a deal has been cut that gives the frum control of the education department. That should shut them up for a while.

The old team are still wandering around looking a bit bemused by it all I'm afraid.

Every society has its taboos and already I can see one emerging here. We try not to mention the real old team. You know. The ones the old team exterminated. At least not within earshot of any of them. A bit gross all round when you think about it.  Don't mention the extermination. Whose? The ones whose paradise on earth we now occupy and must have been what the writers of Genesis had in mind when they described the garden of eden.

You won't believe how easy a sell this was to the Jews.

It's more than three times the size of the old place, is on the other side of the world from the lunatics and would have to be the easiest place on the planet to defend. You could do it with a peashooter. Or so the IDF reckons and they still have plenty of  peashooters.

It was a dream deal from the start. Your guys did the standard helocopter tour of the West Bank and Israel with the Israeli PM who explained at length and in detail the structures, features and issues on the ground and then we organised a standard package tour of Tasmania for every decision maker in Israel. It needed the airforce to get everybody here in time but the deal was stitched up in a week. 

The paperwork was signed in a teahouse in a little mountain village on the road to  St George.  A local solicitor had to be called in to certify that he had explained to the Israelis the consequences of waiving the seven day cooling off period. Quite touching really.

Thanks for the commission by the way. I know it's the standard rate but even half would be far too generous in the circumstances. I would have done it for nothing.  I have donated it in full to help establish a brand new kosher slaughter research centre on King Island. They have promised to name a wing after you.

It's a  sad story all round with the old team I'm sorry to report. Most of their toes were already gone, as you know, and it took the cream of medical science to save what they had left. Often you see them after the pubs are shut, especially when there's a full moon, wandering among the lush native forests* in a melancholy search for their long lost digits. They remind me of the old butler in the courtyard in The Remains of the Day searching by moonlight long into the night for the exact spot where he lost the tray. It is as if they are looking for a lost part of their souls.

Still. We help them as best we can. They are given whatever they ask for.

* [as you know from the news these have been preserved forever as the provisional knesset's first item of business. You won't believe how easy it is to deal with self evident conservation issues once you turf out all the Greens]

Pure Gold

 

i G e O f f

Mate, you're pure gold,  great to see you making a fist of it. Don't worry about the home team, if they didn't look bemused, they wouldn't be normal.

Oh, it would be a good idea to keep some of the home team intact, iHarry reckons we'll need them to exhibit at Side Shows at Easter time.

And that (original) mob the home team exterminated? It only goes to support my initial plea for your assistance - the home team aren't real bright mate (but OK at banjo), and have a perchant for doing silly things with guns.

Mt Wello is looking better than ever, the extra 20,000 metres you added is impressive, and no doubt made the Tibetans feel immediately at home - it was very thoughtful of you Geoff.

All in all, everything going to plan (almost) - looking forward to you transforming WA into a thousand olive orchards in the coming years.

Oh, I nearly forgot, I was speaking to a totally useless bird from across the ditch, she said you could have the South Island for a packet of fags and elocution lessons - waddya reckon?

Cheers mate

BTW, how much is iHarry paying you? 

Marilyn's question

Marilyn, look up the history of the term "antisemitism" and you will find out how it originated. And it wasn't the Jews who did it.

Wellingtonism

An old temple? Mt Zion is to Jerusalem as Mt Wellington is to Hobart. 

Justin, old mate -- speaking strictly for myself, I'd swap Jerusalem for Tasmania in a second. I'd happily throw in  the rest of the land between the river and the sea without a qualm. Christ, I'd even toss in the river and the sea just to sweeten the deal.

But, as Mike ( hiya Mike!) has pointed out, Tasmania is not yours to swap, it is not on offer and never has been, and Israel remains the only homeland the Israelis have.

So it's back to fighting good old fashioned blood curdling antisemitism on an industrial scale for the Israelis I'm afraid. Nice wanky fantasy though. 

What is about the wet western liberal/left and wanky fantasies btw? Could it be  the old folk were right all along? It does make you go blind.

Justin the problem is....

....that Tasmania is no more the Jewish people's homeland than it is the homeland of the Tibetans, yet I don't see you offering Tasmania to the Tibetans.

(Hi Geoff!

Precious

Geoff, don't be provocative.  You are harming your cause.  Turn the other cheek.  Peaceably, not provocatively.

Justin, appreciated the sanity of your comment.  I'm sure Geoff wishes the devil well, as I do.

But Justin, I'm puzzled that you say your roots lay in Tassie.   If they used to lie in that state of mania, where do they lie now, and how were they moved?  Sounds quite a job.

And I thought it was only at some place in the upper Derwent that you were all inbred.

ROOTS GONGS RAZORS

 

 

M i c H a E L

 

Mate, glad to see you haven't sold out to iHarry - yet.

Roots, lay, lie:  now that's a hard one, and of course an invitation to illustrate something rather depraved. But iWinnie won't sink so low.

Having said that, yes my roots "lay" in what is now know as Zionmania; lay of course being past tense.

Now my roots have penetrated the globe, they now lie all over the show - honest.

You see, it's very easy, and having an imaginary menagerie for a brain, really does help one dig, drill down, penetrate, tunnel and fiddle with stuff (which can be colourful) - with determination I might add.

Let me tell you a story about me uncle: Sir Keif, you know, the musician on the roof. Keif once got a gong for digging, well not digging, rather, journalism (he had a big mouth). It was nearly 100 years ago when SK decided to go and help some blokes having an argument with another bunch of blokes, on the other side of the world.

Anyway they needed diggers, and SK like all of us warrior wombats can do that, it comes naturally; why not do something that comes naturally and get paid 3 shillings a week, and an olive (which the greedy bastards never gave him)?

Anyway, while SK was hard at it, he took a few notes about what was going on. Although SK was having the time of his life, the blokes weren't, so SK sent his notes to a newspaper in a big town. The rag published his notes and a whole of heap of readers yelled out: Holy Shit!, or something like that. 

Yep, they were really pleased with SK and gonged him (others hated him) - he had no idea why, nor did the rest of us, but dear old Sir Keif spent the rest of his life jerking off over it. You've already read how dear old SK departed us.

But Keif once said something that I never understood, he said: Lad, a really good journalist needs to have the curiosity of a cat, the intelligence of a rat, the cunning of a fox, and the determination of a wombat" and then he followed: "those are also the qualities of a really evil journalist." Keif then rambled something about a razor's edge, then scrambled up on the roof and rejoiced - again and again.

The red bellies always referred to SK as the "depraved digger", but them guys are really bashful.

Cheers mate

 

iWinnie (hey don't blame me, the offer was too good to refuse, thanks harry).

Justin!

Stop it! You'll go blind.

iCan't...

 

G e o f f

What's up mate, OK, if you wish, you can have, not only  that place on our map, we used to call Tassie (I was worried it was going to come to this), but  WA as well. Great place to grow olives (remember the olive, mmm), lots of sand, and black fellas all over the place; but I'm sure, like Sammy Davis Jnr. they will be quite happy to join the party.

Besides the home team (which I might add, consist of a slightly more complex gene pool than Tassie) could do with a bit of cheering up - a good comic should do the trick: Jerry could do it, but I reckon Lenny is what them sand-molestors need.

Anyway, it's yours if you want, but it will cost one olive, and a bottle of brown muscat.

BTW, Geoff, are you blushing? (the muscat does that to me as well).

Cheers mate.

 

i W i n n i e

 

BTW, you wouldn't be interested in an iLoan, to buy an olive and some cheap plonk, would ya? (harry's got me on a retainer now).

PS, do you think Hamas could use me as a negotiator?

PPS, I will work for commision only.

What is this piece about?

Why Jews have taken semitism unto themselves at the expense of all other semites is a mystery.

No antisemitism here

 Some comments from the last 24 hours chosen at random from just that one NZ paper chosen at random:

All young people in Israel serve in the armed forces and, arguably and by extension, are all agents of the state when abroad.

Its a good thing that our media is making a noise about this suspicious activity as I'm reasonably sure our PM would let it quietly slip away if alloJohn Key is a good friend of Israel, his mother was Jewish and regardless of what the average Kiwi thinks Key will have the last word on the subject as he always does on everything else.


Moderators of these forums should not even allow prickly subjects like these to be put up if they dont want to hear the truth. 96% of the worlds media is connected to or owned by corporations connected to a small nation in the middle East who of course cannot be named for fear of offending God.

Freedom of the press is an illusion. There seems to be a disconnect between the actions of the New Zealand police, the SIS and John Key's repeated denials of any wrongdoing? Bit smelly bro.

Were they spooks, of course not Kerre, they were just poor backpackers who fled NZ leaving behind a dead friend because they were afraid of getting caught doing nothing. To an edumacated person that is a perfectly logic-a-bull explamanation. Spooks in deed, how funny. Not Israel no no no.

Are these people antisemites?

I don't know. See what I mean? Don't ask me.They might be able to mount a defence on the grounds of  blind stupidity.

These New Zealanders are jackasses. It's a wonder they remember to breathe.


The Ususal Suspect

The greatest trick the Devil ever pulled was convincing the world he didn't exist.

I thought that was just a line in a movie, but not now, thanks Geoff.

Anyway, I think iWinnie has finally reckoned out a solution for the Zionist thingy.

OK, as well all know Zionism is a secular movement that simply believes in a Jewish homeland, a safe haven where all cultures can prosper in a secular society. Nope, god didn't dedicate a particular piece of geography to Jews, or so the secular Zionists believe. I suppose, the only real historical attachment Zionists have with Israel is the name: Zion, which relates to an old temple or somthing; but from a secular point of view that wouldn't be any claim to terrority, it's just a relic from the long past. How many secular Christians have an attachment to that hill Jesus got crucified on, not that far from Zion? Probably none, it's just a small part of a big story/idea.

Now that we have sorted out the religious crap, how about a bit of secular pragmatism: Zionists want a Jewish homeland? Well iWinnie has got the property for you.

It truly is a beautiful piece of real estate, far from the maddening crowd, girth by a beautiful blue sea (with lots of yummy fishies). The property is all but vacant, the current residents few, and all related to one another (some multiple times), creating a peaceful ambiance that only Royalty and banjo players would truly appreciate.

It's yours dear friend, fellow believer in the Zionist dream, it's all yours for the grand sum of one olive, and a bottle of brown muscat (the olive is optional). You see this particular piece of real estate needs new blood, intelligence, creativity, good musicians, song writers, entertainers, scientists, doctors, and most of all: a fiddler on the roof. Uncle (Sir) Keif, had that job, but got carried away one afternoon, he was hard at it, but he fell off the roof and broke his neck (both of them).

Yep, you guessed it mate, it's that piece of real estate where me roots lay, that place where life is just one big party, one big family, it is the perfect place for Jews to have as their safe haven, and boy could we use your help Geoff. Of course that safe and secure homeland, far from the maddening crowd, is no other than Tasmania - god's own country.

Have it, it's yours, and of course we could re-name the property:

 

ZIONMANIA

 

Quite apt, and your favourite colour as well, but we can re-paint if you wish.

Oh Geoff, you can have the gig mate, the fiddler job, we reckon you'd be perfect.

But Geoff, if you feel that my eloquent solution is evil, the work of the devil, or even anti-semitic,  then allow me to refer you to the opening quote. But mate, I had nothing to do with it (trust me).

It was this guy.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
© 2005-2011, Webdiary Pty Ltd
Disclaimer: This site is home to many debates, and the views expressed on this site are not necessarily those of the site editors.
Contributors submit comments on their own responsibility: if you believe that a comment is incorrect or offensive in any way,
please submit a comment to that effect and we will make corrections or deletions as necessary.
Margo Kingston Photo © Elaine Campaner

Recent Comments

Paul Walter: wtf? in Gay Marriage: The Hidden Issues 1 day 18 hours ago
Michael Talbot-Wilson: Evasion in Gay Marriage: The Hidden Issues 1 day 22 hours ago
Marilyn Shepherd: 1967 in Post-Osloism: Fraud of the century 2 days 10 hours ago
Paul Walter: God's police in Gay Marriage: The Hidden Issues 2 days 13 hours ago