logo
Published on Webdiary - Founded and Inspired by Margo Kingston (/cms)

Take that, you swine!

By David Roffey
Created 29/04/2009 - 17:23

Bluebottle: "You rotten swines; I told you I'd be deaded"  {Goon Show 3 Jan 1956}

So, should we be stripping the supermarket shelves to lay in siege supplies? Probably not quite yet.

It does seem probable that the WHO will raise the true pandemic flag [1] - Phase 6:  community level outbreaks in at least one other country in a different WHO region - within a short while: the existence of multiple confirmed cases in the US, Scotland and New Zealand makes it look likely that there may soon be confirmed cases of human-to-human transmission in one or more of those: if it were to be the US that would be Phase 5, if in Europe or the Pacific it would be Phase 6. Nonetheless, this still wouldn't be panic time. As that WHO page referenced above says, "Previous pandemics have been characterised by waves of activity spread over months", so any problems this causes will be medium- rather than short-term for those outside Mexico.

No-one right now has any idea whether this is a rerun of SARS, Hong Kong flu or Spanish flu - or if it even makes it onto that scale: the stricter reclassification of deaths by the Mexicans over the next few days may reduce the death toll so far, but won't give any clearer indications. It will take days if not weeks for it to be clearer.

Even if there starts to be a cascade of human-to-human infections spreading from returning holiday-makers, this won't automatically get us up to the base of the disaster scale (unless you're running a hotel in Cancun or a restaurant in Mexico City, in which case economic disaster has already struck). Given the level of publicity on this, there are unlikely to be any people returned from Mexico who aren't going to haul themselves off to a doc pretty much if they feel slightly queasy, let alone sneezy, so there is a good chance it will be contained - and just about every country under threat has put monitoring and quarantine procedures in place over the last few days.

There is, of course, a risk that this will eventually escape the containments and spread worldwide, but that is probably weeks if not months away. Similarly, over-the-top talk about the potential for this to hit poorer countries hard isn't going to come to pass unless they are poorer countries who also have numerous travelers to Mexico in their number (or unless there is a really major breach of containments). This in fact puts Guatemala at the top of the risk list, but it really isn't easy country for fast transmission of anything much (having been in Guatemala near the Mexican border just last year visiting my daughter who was working there, I can attest to this!).

Be alert but not alarmed!  

ADDED: I was asked (not on Webdiary) what would cause me to be more concerned:

 PS: here's a supremely badly timed report from the LA Times on 15 April 2009: Mexico's tourist zones much safer than many in U.S. [2]


Source URL:
/cms/?q=node/2796