logo
Published on Webdiary - Founded and Inspired by Margo Kingston (http://webdiary.com.au/cms)

Politicised science

By Hamish Alcorn
Created 14/02/2006 - 12:56

Did anyone watch 4 Corners [1] last night? Here [2] is a transcript. Climate change has been an important theme on Webdiary and I personally think it is the most important issue on the planet. The most recent thread was Sue Russell's The end of the world as we know it (do you feel fine?) [2], but there has also been Climate change update 3: Greenhouse 2005 [2], and a number of others by David Roffey [2], Changing Climate Change [2] by Jeffrey D Sachs and Climate change: blindingly obvious or relatively unimportant? [2] by J Bradford DeLong and Bjørn Lomborg.

Here is a brief extract from Janine Cohen's 4-Corners report "The Greenhouse Mafia [3]":

JANINE COHEN: Kevin Hennessy is the coordinator of the CSIRO's Climate Impact Group. One of his jobs is to talk about the potential impacts of climate change. But there are some likely impacts of climate change that are clearly a no-go zone. Some scientists believe that there'll be more environmental refugees. Is that a possibility?

KEVIN HENNESSY, CSIRO IMPACT GROUP: I can't really comment on that.

JANINE COHEN: Why can't you comment on that?

KEVIN HENNESSY, CSIRO IMPACT GROUP: That's, that's, er... No, I can't comment on that.

JANINE COHEN: Is that part of editorial policy? You can't comment on things that affect immigration?

KEVIN HENNESSY, CSIRO IMPACT GROUP: No, I can't comment on that.

JANINE COHEN: Can I just ask you why you can't comment?

KEVIN HENNESSY, CSIRO IMPACT GROUP: Not on camera.

JANINE COHEN: Oh, OK. But is it a policy thing?

KEVIN HENNESSY, CSIRO IMPACT GROUP: I can't comment on that.

Well, we can safely say that Webdiary has been trying harder to keep you informed about this issue than the Government.

To kick this thread off then, here is a Press Release from Greens Senator Christine Milne's office, entitled, "Independent investigation needed into corruption of climate change policy.":

Claims that the fossil fuel industry had unprecedented access to confidential Commonwealth government processes and the silencing of senior climate change scientists require an independent investigation, the Australian Greens said today.

The allegations point to a corruption of the process for developing government policy on the most critical environmental issue facing the nation, Greens climate change spokesperson Senator Christine Milne said.

"The claims aired last night on ABC Four Corners by reputable scientists and a former ministerial staffer will trouble every Australian who cares about accountability and the government's response to climate change," Senator Milne said in Canberra.

"Attempts by government ministers and the fossil fuel industry to dismiss the claims will not wash.

"This is not how government should operate - providing access for parties with vested interests to draft cabinet and ministerial documents in an apparent attempt to undermine policy responses to address the pollution their businesses cause.

"Is this why the government has refused to set greenhouse gas emission reduction targets, to ratify the Kyoto Protocol and to acknowledge that sea level rise in the Pacific could displace many people who will seek refuge in Australia?

"Australia's global reputation has been severely damaged by the scandal enveloping the Australian Wheat Board, private companies and the government over the sale of wheat to Iraq.

"These claims about industry involvement at the highest level of
developing climate change policy further besmirch Australia's
international standing and contrast with Prime Minister Howard's attempts to improve governance in our region.

"The government must appoint a suitable person with judicial experience to conduct an independent investigation, with the powers of a Royal Commission, to examine these most serious claims."


Source URL:
http://webdiary.com.au/cms/?q=node/1248