Webdiary - Independent, Ethical, Accountable and Transparent
header_02 home about login header_06
header_07
search_bar_left
date_box_left
date_box_right.jpg
search_bar_right
sidebar-top content-top

Archive - 2005

Submitted by Margo Kingston on November 7, 2005 - 11:22am.
Margo Kingston

Biography

Margo Kingston was the political commentator for the Sydney Morning Herald online (www.smh.com.au), edited the Fairfax Webdiary (www.smh.com.au/webdiary) and until 13 June 2004, wrote a weekly column on politics in the Sun Herald. Margo went independent and created Margo Kingston's Webdiary in July 2005.

She was born in Maryborough, Queensland, in 1959, grew up in the North Queensland sugar city of Mackay and graduated with an Arts Law degree from the University of Queensland. She practised as a solicitor and lectured in business law before joining Brisbane’s Courier-Mail newspaper. She has since worked for the Times on Sunday, the Melbourne Age and the Canberra Times, and as the political researcher for Jana Wendt on Channel Nine’s A Current Affair. She was Phillip Adams’s ‘Canberra Babylon’ commentator on the ABC’s Late Night Live for five years.
left
right
[ category: ]
spacer
Submitted by Betty Birskys on November 7, 2005 - 11:07am.
Betty Birskys: how did we get here?

"As an eighty-year-old 'war veteran' (VAD and AAMWS) and supposedly one of John Howard’s demographic supporters, I am dismayed by the way Australia has been going under this Prime Minister, and very, very depressed by where we have finished up. What has become of the dreams that many in my generation had, as we rejoiced in the defeat of Hitler and the Japanese Empire? ... Like many then, I believed in the promise of a Brave New World, without wars and poverty, and in Australia good public education and health care and social security - a fair go - for all. I never dreamt of anything but honesty and decency in public life..." Betty Birskys

left
right
[ category: ]
spacer
Submitted by Carmen Lawrence on November 7, 2005 - 4:39am.
How authoritarian governments exploit our fear of annihilation to steal our freedoms, by Carmen Lawrence

"Ours is a time in which the politics of fear is in full flight, although it may be argued that exploitation of fear is the politicians' normal 'stock in trade'. Fear is the most powerful tool of manipulation available to our leaders and such manipulation is a form of abuse. Pressed into the employ of the current Government's narrow interpretation of Australia's "national interest" such techniques can, as Burke puts it, "break and dissolve the bonds which linked individuals with broader social obligations and forms of collective social organisation". They poison our relationships with one another and create a "more selfish and atomised" citizenship attuned to self-interest and suspicious of the claims of others. As many authoritarian leaders have well understood, a populace is best controlled when it's afraid - controlled and diverted. The survival of our democracies depends not on our capacity to hit back at the terrorists, but on our capacity to think for ourselves." Carmen Lawrence

left
right
[ category: ]
spacer
Submitted by Margo Kingston on November 7, 2005 - 1:31am.
Why free speech is worth dying for, by Menzies

"All things considered, the worst crime of fascism and its twin brother, German national socialism, is their suppression of free thought and free speech. Now, why is this freedom of real importance to humanity? The answer is that what appears to be today’s truth is frequently tomorrow’s error. Hence, if truth is to emerge and in the long run be triumphant, the process of free debate - the untrammelled clash of opinion - must go on. There are fascist tendencies in all countries - a sort of latent tyranny. And they exist, be it remembered, in radical as well as in conservative quarters. Suppression of attack, which is based upon suppression of really free thought, is the instinctive weapon of the vested interest. Power is apt to produce a kind of drunkenness, and it needs the cold douche of the critic to correct it." Sir Robert Menzies, 1942

left
right
[ category: ]
spacer
Submitted by Malcolm B Duncan on November 6, 2005 - 12:43pm.
The view on the looming 'orizon

"For over 30 years now, I have had a close association with Alphonse de Ponce, Astrologer, seer and clairvoyant. Given the political turmoil on so many fronts at the moment, I asked Alphonse if he would cast the gall-stones and tell me what the future held. The results were so startling I thought they should be shared with Webdiarists without delay." Malcolm B Duncan

left
right
[ category: ]
spacer
Submitted by Margo Kingston on November 6, 2005 - 3:44am.
Fighting for freedom from fear, by Sir Robert Menzies

"We must frankly admit that fear has not only been a large and deadly element in international relations. It has also been a recognized and potent instrument of domestic policy. Indeed, a powerful case might be made out for the view that the emotion of fear is the most significant of all the emotions on the field of politics... Nothing can be worse for democracy than to adopt the practice of permitting knowledge to be overthrown by ignorance. If I have honestly and thoughtfully arrived at a certain conclusion on a public question and my electors disagree with me, my first duty is to endeavour to persuade them that my view is right. If I fail in this, my second duty will be to accept the electoral consequences and not to run away from them. Fear can never be a proper or useful ingredient in those mutual relations of respect and goodwill which ought to exist between the elector and the elected. In time of war it is the absence of fear in individuals and groups which gives dignity and strength to the nation's bearing in the midst of difficulties. It is the presence of fear and the yielding to it which produces hysteria and greed and burden-dodging."  Sir Robert Menzies, 1942

left
right
[ category: ]
spacer
Submitted by Margo Kingston on November 6, 2005 - 2:59am.
Menzies on Hatred as an instrument of War Policy

"If we are to view war problems from a national point of view and - what is even better - from a world point of view, then we must inevitably conclude  that if this war with all its tragedy breeds into us a deep-seated and enduring spirit of hatred, then the peace when it comes will be merely the prelude to disaster and not an end of it. It is an offence to an honest citizen to imagine that the cold, evil and repulsive spirit of racial hatred must be substituted for honest and brave indignation if his greatest effort is to be obtained.  It is not highfalutin to have a noble and decent cause in war. It is the very moral height of our great argument which alone can reconcile the mother to the death of her son in battle. This war is no sordid conflict of racial animosities. If it were, it could never end in your lifetime or mine. We should refuse to take the honest and natural and passing passions of the human heart and degrade them into sinister and bitter policy. We shall, in other words, do well if we leave the dignity and essential nobility of our cause unstained and get on urgently with the business of so working, so fighting, and so sacrificing ourselves that the cause emerges triumphant and the healing benefits of its success become available as a blessing not merely for us but for all mankind." Sir Robert Menzies, 1942

left
right
[ category: ]
spacer
Submitted by Carmen Lawrence on November 6, 2005 - 1:58am.
Carmen Lawrence on fear and public policy

"One of the reasons offered for adopting democracy as a system of government is people's desire to be protected from state-sponsored fear - fear of persecution and death, arbitrary theft of property and discrimination. Democracy has been described as a "fear-less" or "fear-resolving" system and one of the recurrent themes in the evolution of democracies is that government by fear is inherently illegitimate. Most democracies limit the use of fear as a political weapon by developing institutions which ensure basic freedoms and civil liberties." Carmen Lawrence

left
right
[ category: ]
spacer
Submitted by Guest Contributor on November 5, 2005 - 11:33am.
Justice Alastair Nicholson on government terror, media complicity and the death of a responsible Opposition

"In considering this proposed legislation, it is important to remember that in Australia there is no effective human rights framework surrounding the new anti-terrorism legislation. Unlike other western democracies, we have no Bill of Rights and therefore no check upon extreme legislation of this type other than what can be found in the Constitution. The Australian Constitution contains no significant human rights clauses and the few that are there have been so read down by the High Court as to be almost meaningless....the media at least, has become inured to governmental attacks upon our liberties, or to take a more sinister view, that it or parts of it are engaging in self censorship...I regard the role of the Opposition as even more worrying than the role of the Government. It would appear that a more critical role is being played by the Government's own backbench and the Fairfax press than by the Opposition. Even worse is the behaviour of the States and Territories who have delivered a trump card to the Government that may even be sufficient to overcome the fragile protection that the Constitution offers." The Honourable Alastair Nicholson AO RFD QC

left
right
[ category: ]
spacer
Submitted by Margo Kingston on November 5, 2005 - 7:49am.
Welfare to work: creating the economically disabled?

"The NATSEM modelling demonstrates that without significant change to aspects of Newstart, such as to the income test, or to taxation treatment of additional earned income or to the activity test, individuals with a disability and women and men supporting children who attempt to improve their circumstances by entering the workforce face shocking Government imposed income losses. They'll not be able to pay the rent, put food on the table, and if they are on a part-allowance, they'll lose up to 75 cents in each dollar earned." Marie Coleman

left
right
[ category: ]
spacer
Submitted by Margo Kingston on November 5, 2005 - 3:49am.
IR Bill: links update #2

|| Unions plan industrial action || Lawyers say new IR laws a 'dog's breakfast' || Eighteen MPs ejected from Parliament over two days || Joyce raises doubts over support for new IR legislation || more... ||

left
right
[ category: ]
spacer
Submitted by Jozef Imrich on November 5, 2005 - 1:15am.
Anti-terrorism laws - links update #11

Parliament releases Anti-Terrorism Bill 2005 (Cth) and Anti-Terrorism Bill 2005 No 2 (Cth) - links here to speeches, ammendments and Bills Digest.

|| Howard in hot water over revealing operation. || NZ PM Helen Clarke -  Australian officials have confirmed that there is no imminent threat of terrorist attacks. || Senior analyst says not conspiracy but believes Howard briefed earlier than Monday. ||

left
right
[ category: ]
spacer
Submitted by Jozef Imrich on November 5, 2005 - 1:15am.
Anti-terrorism laws - links update #11

Parliament releases Anti-Terrorism Bill 2005 (Cth) and Anti-Terrorism Bill 2005 No 2 (Cth) - links here to speeches, amendments and Bills Digest.

|| Howard in hot water over revealing operation. || NZ PM Helen Clarke -  Australian officials have confirmed that there is no imminent threat of terrorist attacks. || Senior analyst says not conspiracy but believes Howard briefed earlier than Monday. ||

left
right
[ category: ]
spacer
Submitted by Wayne Sanderson on November 4, 2005 - 11:11pm.
The Daily Briefing 4/11/05

|| Richard Ackland won't get fooled again || Tony Fitzgerald on reforming Australian democracy  || Nicholas Lemann on Plame, politics and the press || Jeffrey Goldberg on foreign policy and Iraq  || Collection of essays on Iraq and the Bush Doctrine  || Francis Fukuyama on Islam and European multiculturalism  || Peter Church on Afghanistan's new Parliament  || Hilwiah Roche on why Gandhi didn't win the Nobel prize || D.T. Max on literary Darwinism || Ariel Levy profiles Maureen Dowd || Nicolas Riou on the politics of consumption || Spanish s*x guide furore ||

left
right
[ category: ]
spacer
Submitted by Wayne Sanderson on November 4, 2005 - 11:11pm.
The Daily Briefing 4/11/05

|| National round-up early edition ||

left
right
[ category: ]
spacer
Submitted by Margo Kingston on November 4, 2005 - 9:05pm.
IR Bill: links update #1

Begining today, resource and links updates on the new IR legislation. This first collection comes from the Parliament of Australia Parliamentary Library.

left
right
[ category: ]
spacer
Submitted by Guest Contributor on November 4, 2005 - 9:54am.
Andrews v Beazley: first strikes in Parliamentary IR debate

Andrews: That is what Work Choices is all about – securing the future prosperity of Australian individuals and families. ... Work Choices does this by accommodating the greater demand for choice and flexibility in our workplaces. It continues a process of evolution, begun over a decade ago, towards a system that trusts Australian men and women to make their own decisions in the workplace and to do so in a way that best suits them.

Beazley: It is the product of an extreme, outdated ideology. An ideology that has nothing to do with the challenges Australia faces in the first quarter of the 21st century - nothing to do with the nation's economic needs. ... It's the most savage attack on the values of Australian society and the security of working families that I've seen in 25 years in this Parliament.

left
right
[ category: ]
spacer
Submitted by Margo Kingston on November 4, 2005 - 9:54am.
Andrews v Beazley: first strikes in Parliamentary IR debate

Andrews: That is what Work Choices is all about – securing the future prosperity of Australian individuals and families. ... Work Choices does this by accommodating the greater demand for choice and flexibility in our workplaces. It continues a process of evolution, begun over a decade ago, towards a system that trusts Australian men and women to make their own decisions in the workplace and to do so in a way that best suits them.

Beazley: It is the product of an extreme, outdated ideology. An ideology that has nothing to do with the challenges Australia faces in the first quarter of the 21st century - nothing to do with the nation's economic needs. ... It's the most savage attack on the values of Australian society and the security of working families that I've seen in 25 years in this Parliament.

left
right
[ category: ]
spacer
Submitted by Margo Kingston on November 4, 2005 - 1:50am.
Will Howard investigate seditious leaks on terror scare against his public wishes? (rhetorical question)

G'day. I don't suppose anyone in the Opposition will dare make these obvious points today, so here goes. Where did the newspapers get their information from of the supposed details of the specific intelligence which Howard claimed triggered his emergency amendments to terror laws yesterday? I've read the news stories linked in today's Daily Briefing, and lots of detail - mostly stated as fact and unsourced - is there in black and white. I've set them out below.Yet Howard himself said over and over at his press conference yesterday that he wouldn't, indeed COULDN'T go into any detail IN THE NATIONAL INTEREST.

left
right
[ category: ]
spacer
Submitted by Margo Kingston on November 4, 2005 - 1:50am.
Will Howard investigate seditious leaks on terror scare against his public wishes (rhetorical question)

G'day. I don't suppose anyone in the Opposition will dare make these obvious points today, so here goes. Where did the newspapers get their information from of the supposed details of the specific intelligence which Howard claimed triggered his emergency amendments to terror laws yesterday? I've read the news stories linked in today's Daily Briefing, and lots of detail - mostly stated as fact and unsourced - is there in black and white. I've set them out below.Yet Howard himself said over and over at his press conference yesterday that he wouldn't, indeed COULDN'T go into any detail IN THE NATIONAL INTEREST.

left
right
[ category: ]
spacer
Submitted by Margo Kingston on November 4, 2005 - 1:41am.
Anti-terrorism laws - links update #10


Key national anti-terrorism body 'not activated'

ABC Online November 3, 2005. 9:41am (AEDT)
ACT Chief Minister Jon Stanhope says a key national counter-terrorism body was not informed of the latest terrorism threat. - http://www.abc.net.au/news/newsitems/200511/s1496633.htm

True test is just around the corner
The Age, November 3, 2005, By MICHELLE GRATTAN
ONE test of the need to rush a minor change to the nation's anti-terrorism laws through Parliament today will come almost immediately. This week the Government has received specific information of a terrorist threat to Australia. The PM says passage of the amendment will strengthen agencies' capacity to respond. If authorities require this instant legal finetuning, they'll presumably act at once. Logically, we should see arrests over the next few days. - http://www.theage.com.au/articles/2005/11/02/1130823280998.html

left
right
[ category: ]
spacer
Submitted by Jozef Imrich on November 4, 2005 - 1:41am.
Anti-terrorism laws - links update #10


Key national anti-terrorism body 'not activated'

ABC Online November 3, 2005. 9:41am (AEDT)
ACT Chief Minister Jon Stanhope says a key national counter-terrorism body was not informed of the latest terrorism threat. - http://www.abc.net.au/news/newsitems/200511/s1496633.htm

True test is just around the corner
The Age, November 3, 2005, By MICHELLE GRATTAN
ONE test of the need to rush a minor change to the nation's anti-terrorism laws through Parliament today will come almost immediately. This week the Government has received specific information of a terrorist threat to Australia. The PM says passage of the amendment will strengthen agencies' capacity to respond. If authorities require this instant legal finetuning, they'll presumably act at once. Logically, we should see arrests over the next few days. - http://www.theage.com.au/articles/2005/11/02/1130823280998.html

left
right
[ category: ]
spacer
Submitted by Wayne Sanderson on November 3, 2005 - 10:55pm.
The Daily Briefing 3/11/05

|| Simon Jenkins says don't politicise terrorist criminals || David Broder on President 'Push Over' || Maureen Dowd on the paranoid White House || Stephen Walt says Iraq is Bush's fault || Martin Indyk says Iran's bluster is serious || Wynton Marsalis on jazz citizenship and New Orleans || Mukhtaran Bibi 'woman of the year' || Robert Andrews on the chat room for IT innovators ||

left
right
[ category: ]
spacer
Submitted by Wayne Sanderson on November 3, 2005 - 10:55pm.
The Daily Briefing 3/11/05

|| Simon Jenkins says don't politicise terrorist criminals || David Broder on President 'Push Over' || Maureen Dowd on the paranoid White House || Stephen Walt says Iraq is Bush's fault || Martin Indyk says Iran's bluster is serious || Wynton Marsalis on jazz citizenship and New Orleans || Mukhtaran Bibi 'woman of the year' || Robert Andrews on the chat room for IT innovators ||

left
right
[ category: ]
spacer
Submitted by Jozef Imrich on November 3, 2005 - 6:00am.
Anti-terrorism laws - links update #9

Late addition - Legal profession opposes Anti-Terror Bill and provides SUMMARY OF KEY MEASURES TO GIVE TO FRIENDS AND INTERESTED CITIZENS 

Stanhope excluded. ASIO warns of attack but no increase in alert and more... Change of venue for HEROC Darwin forum tomorrow with John von Doussa.

left
right
[ category: ]
spacer
Submitted by Jozef Imrich on November 3, 2005 - 6:00am.
Anti-terrorism laws - links update #9

Late addition - Legal profession opposes Anti-Terror Bill and provides SUMMARY OF KEY MEASURES TO GIVE TO FRIENDS AND INTERESTED CITIZENS 

Stanhope excluded. ASIO warns of attack but no increase in alert and more... Change of venue for HEROC Darwin forum tomorrow with John von Doussa.

left
right
[ category: ]
spacer
Submitted by Margo Kingston on November 3, 2005 - 3:40am.
Serious new terrorist threat to Oz, says JWH, so why no increased terror alert?

G'day. The PM and Mr Ruddock have just told reporters that a little bit of the terror laws package will be rushed through the House of Reps after question time, then through the Senate tomorrow arvo. It will, Howard said, alter current law referring to 'the' terrorist act to 'a' terrorist act. He wouldn't say why this particular change was urgent, and ensured there were no informed questions asked on behalf of Australians by insisting that he'd give reporters a statement on the detail AFTER he'd said his bit and gone to lunch.

left
right
[ category: ]
spacer
Submitted by Margo Kingston on November 3, 2005 - 2:21am.
688 pages of IR legislation out now, but be quick or they'll be law before you know it

G'day. Here we go folks. This morning the government released most of its mega Industrial Relations package of legislation. Actually, it didn't do it until AFTER the minister Kevin Andrews introduced the bills into the House of Representatives flanked by a smug PM. That led to a shit-fight for an hour on the floor of the House, because House rules require that MPs each get a copy of a proposed law before the debate starts. Fair enough, eh? The government didn't bother with that. The People's House is a sham, after all.

left
right
[ category: ]
spacer
Submitted by Wayne Sanderson on November 2, 2005 - 11:14pm.
The Daily Briefing 2/11/05

||  Dina Exxat on the Arab Leaque's role in Iraq ||  Robert Skidelsky on the rise of China ||  Wang Shuhai says China needs philosophers ||  David Clark says Blair will replace Britain's nuclear weapons ||  Laurie Oakes on the 30th anniversary of the dismissal ||  Paul Kahn on reconciling the erotic with the political ||  Alister McGrath on atheists hoping for a new Enlightenment ||  Caitlin Moran on this culturally empty decade ||  Report on the Guardian's social, ethical, environmental audit || 

left
right
[ category: ]
spacer
Submitted by Guest Contributor on November 2, 2005 - 8:54am.
ASIO questioned over Scott Parkin: the transcript

Senator BOB BROWN - Had Mr Parkin ever taken part in a violent or dangerous protest-that you are aware of?
(ASIO Chief) Mr O'Sullivan - While he was in Australia, do you mean?
Senator BOB BROWN - In Australia or elsewhere.
Mr O'Sullivan - I understand there was some background while he was in the United States, but I believe the answer to your question in respect of Australia is no.

left
right
[ category: ]
spacer
© 2005-2011, Webdiary Pty Ltd
Disclaimer: This site is home to many debates, and the views expressed on this site are not necessarily those of the site editors.
Contributors submit comments on their own responsibility: if you believe that a comment is incorrect or offensive in any way,
please submit a comment to that effect and we will make corrections or deletions as necessary.
Margo Kingston Photo © Elaine Campaner

Recent Comments

David Roffey: {whimper} in Not with a bang ... 13 weeks 2 days ago
Jenny Hume: So long mate in Not with a bang ... 13 weeks 2 days ago
Fiona Reynolds: Reds (under beds?) in Not with a bang ... 13 weeks 4 days ago
Justin Obodie: Why not, with a bang? in Not with a bang ... 13 weeks 4 days ago
Fiona Reynolds: Dear Albatross in Not with a bang ... 13 weeks 4 days ago
Michael Talbot-Wilson: Good luck in Not with a bang ... 13 weeks 4 days ago
Fiona Reynolds: Goodnight and good luck in Not with a bang ... 13 weeks 6 days ago
Margo Kingston: bye, babe in Not with a bang ... 14 weeks 2 days ago